Phantox's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Lilium]

Very nice

Very nice movie. Here's what I think of it:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where perfect. You're a very good drawer.
2. Music: Music was great. It went with the flash very well. It's from the opening of Elfen Lied am I right?
3. Plot: Plot was very interesting. Cruel and sad at the same time. Love it.

Cons:
1. Voices: No voices. You should have used voices instead of text.
2. The font of the text was way to simple for a movie like this. You should have added a weirder looking text so that way it went with the movie.

That's all. Al tho this isn't much of a movie and I just can't rate it that high I still gave it a good score because I really liked it. Anyways, great job.

[ShortySticks]

Bad

Bad movie... Here's what I think of it:

Pros:
1. Music: Music was alright. Not that good but alright.
2. Animation: Animation was good. The characters moved alright.

Cons:
1. Graphics: Graphics where horrible. You need to work on that a bit more.
2. Plot: No plot at all. Just some stick figures dying.
3. Length: Way to short.

That's all. Work on graphics, plot, and length, and you might be able to make something better.

[Sherlock Holmes Christmas]

Great!

Great movie you got there. Here's what I think of it:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where very nice. I really liked them. Good job on that.
2. Voice Acting: Voice acting was great. Very very good on that.
3. Plot: Plot was interesting. I really liked it.
4. Humor: The movie had some very funny parts. Nice job

Cons:
1. No scene select. This is a long movie so I really recommend you put one in. It's useful because if someone wants to go to their favorite part, they could just select it instead of having to go through the whole movie.

That's all. Really nice movie. I loved the plot.

Pigmash responds:

Thanks, and Ill try and learn how to do scene selection some time

[Scott and Duke ep.7]

...

Not that good of a flash. Here's my opinion on it.

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where alright. Not too good, not to bad either.

Cons:
1. Lip Sync: Lip Sync was horrible... I suggest you work on that a bit more.
2. Voice Acting: Voice acting was also very bad. Work on that a bit more too.
3. Humor: Horrible. I didn't laugh at all.
4. Plot: Some guys talking about going to the moon. Boring... Sorry.

That's all. I really suggest you work on lip sync, VA, and humor. The graphics are alright. If you need help on the lip sync, check out the tutorials section. They have some nice tutorials on LS there.

Linked responds:

I appreciate the constructive criticism! Although, if you look at more recent work you'd see that i've improved a lot.

[It's a Halo Thing]

Awesome!

Awesome movie. Very funny. Here's what I think of it:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where great. They weren't bad at all but you could work a bit more on the faces. Still great tho.
2. Animation: The characters moved smoothly. Very nice on that.
3. Voice acting: The voice acting was great. Awesome job.
4. Sounds: The sounds where very nice. Very clear. Good selection too.
5. Humor: This movie was very funny. Funnier than most of the Halo parodies you see around Newgrounds.

Cons:
1. In my opinion, you could have worked a bit more on Cortana. Her eyes and head where way to big.
2. I didn't like the Mini Fridge part much. I didn't find it funny at all.

Anyways, that's all. I really enjoyed this movie. Good luck on the next parts. I'll look forward to them.

[HALOMEN2]

...

I'm disappointed a bit on this... I was expecting more from you. Here's my opinion on the flash:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics are very nice. I like them a lot.
2. Plot: Plot was alright but I think it would have been better if you kept it just MC, Steve and the Captain.

Cons:
1. Humor: I didn't find this one as funny the last one. Well... not funny at all.
2. You should have made the Master Chief a bit more quiet like you did on the first one and not have made him talk without his helmet.
3. Some characters, such as the guy from Half-Life, had a very large head... Like 5x their body size. It would be better if you resized them a bit.

That's all. I was expecting this one to be a lot better than the first but Unfortunately it's not. If you make a #3, please make it better.

danomano65 responds:

You are 15. You have hentai all over your profile...
Please.

Reevaluate your position in the world before assessing my hardwork.

[Madness Redeemer]

Great job

Better than last but somethings could be better... Here's what I think of it:

Pros:
1. Plot: It's good to see that you added a simple plot to it. Makes it more interesting.
2. Blood: It's good that you added blood. Makes it look a lot better.
3. Sounds: Sound effects where good but it would be better if you would have added more of a type of "action" type of song instead of the one you put in.

Cons:
1. Still no replay button...
2. In my opinion, you should add a small "beep" sound when the movie starts so the watcher knows that the movie started and switches the window on time and doesn't miss much of what happens at the beginning.
3. On some frames, (like the one after he kills all the zombies) you can see a small something at the top of the screen. There are 2 of these. One after he kills the zombies and 2 when the elevator is going up.

That's all. This one is a lot better than the first one. Great job

[Madness Combat]

Great!

This is a great flash. Here's my review on it:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where OK but hey, It's madness.
2. It doesn't have a plot but it's still great to watch people kill each other in different ways.
3. Sound: Sound was funny. I loved listening to it while watching. The gun and hit effects where also very good.
4. Loved the guy at the back dancing while there was a massacre taking place

Cons:
1. Gore: No blood at all. I think it's bad having a flash about killing without any blood.
2. The fists moved a bit slow in the beginning but as the movie progressed, it got better.
3. No replay button... Sucks not to have one and having to re-open the window or having to press rewind.

Anyways, this was a great flash, Krinkels. Gonna watch the other ones now. =)

[Biography: Master Chief]

Not bad

This movie was great. Very funny. Here's what I think about it:

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics weren't bad. I think they fit well with the movie.
2. Plot: The plot was good. Quite different from what you see in NG nowadays.
3. Humor: Humor was great. There where some very funny parts in there especially the part where Bob is talking and the MC kills him.
4. The narrator was extremely funny how you made pictures go with what he was saying was epic.

Cons:
I didn't find anything that I didn't like in it except the part where the marine inside the Pelican starts saying "This is to high" That part was unfunny but the part where he throws himself off is great.

That's all of my review. I hope to see more. Great job

[:the Composer:]

Awesome

This was a very touching movie. Here's what I think of it.

Pros:
1. Graphics: Graphics where great. Not bad.
2. Plot: The plot was fantastic. Very touching. Very different from what you see in NG these days.

Cons:
I didn't find anything I didn't like in the movie I just recommend you work on the blinking a bit.

Overall, excellent job. Added to my favorites. Keep it up!